Our Staff

Pastor Peter Plagenz

Pastor Peter Plagenz, his wife, Lauren and their son, Titus joined our church family in March 2020.  Peter grew up in Manchester, WI.  He graduated from Martin Luther College where he met his wife Lauren. They were married August, 2015, in Rochester, MN. He graduated from Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary in 2018.  Peter loves any outdoor activities including camping, hiking, canoeing, fishing, and hunting. He also enjoys staying active with running and basketball. The Lord has since added to the Plagenz family: Phoebe (2020), Matthea (2022), and Gideon (2024).

Contact: pastorplagenz@stpaulswr.org

 



 

Pastor Jeremiah Wallander

Pastor Jeremiah Wallander, his wife Kelli, and their children, Myra and Titus, joined St. Paul's in July 2026. Jerry and Kelli are originally from Appleton, WI, and both are graduates of Fox Valley Lutheran High School (Kelli '13, Jerry '15). After high school, Jerry attended Martin Luther College in the pre-seminary program studying Greek and Hebrew and graduating in 2019. Jerry then attended Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary and graduated in 2023. Upon graduation, Jerry was called to serve as New Testament instructor and dorm supervisor at Michigan Lutheran Seminary. After three years teaching New Testament at MLS, he accepted the call to serve St. Paul's as the youth & family pastor. Jerry has a passion for youth ministry and showing Jesus to teens and young adults. He also enjoys exercise, studying, literature, film, photography, drumming, and all Wisconsin sports. 

Contact: pastorwallander@stpaulswr.org